Listen to this article

Leigh Genesis Footballer Cleared After Six-Match Ban for Questioning Trans Opponent Is Overturned

10 posts • GPT (4.1)

Updated May 10, 2025, 02:42 PM

Cerys Vaughan, an 18-year-old footballer for Leigh Genesis, was sanctioned by the Football Association (FA) after asking a transgender opponent from Manchester Laces, who reportedly had a beard, 'Are you a man?' during a pre-season friendly in Lancashire in July 2024. Vaughan, then 17 and on the autism assessment pathway, raised the matter with the referee, citing concerns over fairness and safety.

Following a complaint made through the anti-discrimination group Kick It Out, Vaughan was charged with improper conduct, including an aggravated breach referencing gender reassignment. She was found guilty by a disciplinary panel and handed a six-match ban, with four matches suspended for 12 months, and was required to complete an online equality and diversity course. The disciplinary process included a three-hour video call that left Vaughan in tears and impacted her A-level PE studies.

Vaughan denied the charges, stating that her question was not intended to be offensive but to seek clarity on the rules. Her mother and the Free Speech Union supported her throughout the process. Vaughan appealed the decision, and in February 2025, an FA appeal board found that she had not received a fair hearing, quashed the original ruling, and ordered a new process.

The case was dropped in April 2025 after the complainant withdrew, and Vaughan's record was cleared. Vaughan has since revealed her identity publicly and is demanding an apology from the FA, stating that the process was stressful and had a significant impact on her life.

The incident and subsequent disciplinary action sparked protests by women's rights campaigners, including demonstrations at Wembley, and prompted scrutiny of the FA's gender eligibility policy. Minutes after Vaughan was informed her case was dropped, the UK Supreme Court issued a ruling defining a woman based on biological sex. Shortly after, the FA announced a ban on transgender women from playing in women's football in England.

More breaking stories on DeepNewz — updated live.

#Cerys Vaughan #Leigh Genesis #Football Association #FA #Manchester Laces #Lancashire #Vaughan #Kick It Out #PE #Free Speech Union #Wembley #UK Supreme Court #England

Associated Financial Markets

More financial news and market updates→

Related Prediction Markets

Caitlin Clark stalker pleads guilty?

Andrew Tate guilty of human trafficking in 2025?

•

View market suggestions→

Sources

bbc.co.uk(3)telegraph.co.uk(3)dailymail.co.uk(2)gbnews.com

Sonia Sodha

@soniasodha

The ⁦@FA⁩ must apologise to Cerys Vaughan for its appalling treatment of this female footballer when she was just 17. Its misogyny is plain to see. Teenage footballer banned for transgender comment wants apology from Football Association - BBC Sport https://t.co/u5KoJmECdc

The Free Speech Union

@SpeechUnion

Cerys Vaughan, the teenage footballer banned for asking a trans opponent “Are you a man?”, has won her appeal. The FSU supported her throughout — funding her legal team and helping overturn the FA’s flawed decision. Read her Telegraph interview here: https://t.co/hR9qfirhTg

The Free Speech Union

@SpeechUnion

🚨 Teenage footballer and FSU member Cerys Vaughan was banned from women’s football by an FA disciplinary panel, for asking a bearded opponent: “Are you a man?” With our help, she appealed and the FA’s ruling was quashed — but only after a Kafkaesque process and a six-game https://t.co/QyZv350te1