The debate over the morality of dropping nuclear bombs on Japan during WWII has sparked controversy. Tucker Carlson condemns the act as evil, while others argue it was necessary to end the war and prevent further suffering. Ben Shapiro defends the U.S.'s decision, citing the potential loss of life if conventional forces were used. General Eisenhower and others claim Japan was already surrendering, making the bombings unnecessary. Discussions also mention the bombing of Dresden as a comparison, with varying views on its justification.
I've spent quite a bit of time in Dresden. It was horrible what happened to Dresden on Feb 13, 1945. That being said, Dresden's population in 1945 was around 630,000. So 600,000 of those that lived in Dresden were refugees fleeing Bolsheviks? No. This is incorrect. There… https://t.co/mAoIaqGWEc
Why am I not surprised that this dumb bitch doesn't know the history of the Pacific theater in WWII?? Japan was not in defensive retreat. We were kicking their ass and then they started going kamakazi vowing to sacrifice millions of their own people. Enough with this idiot. https://t.co/9mvUcQlTCU
I’m just glad you have enough moral clarity to admit that what happened in Dresden was a sinister war crime. I would debate any person on the absurd notion that dropping nukes (months AFTER German surrender) on civilian cities in a country that had been on defensive retreat for… https://t.co/cMYNKM2Eee
Candace Owens is right. The bombing of Dresden was a war crime. However, dropping the A-bomb on Japan was not a war crime. And Israel accidentally killing civilians which Hamas hides behind, is not a war crime either, as she is going to insinuate. https://t.co/OtIGmDL2ZD
if one does not wish to drop a nuclear bomb on another, that is a good thing. all war involves killing innocent people, that is a bad thing. the fact that the united states dropped two nuclear bombs on Japan at the end of WWII and immediately after Japan surrendered with no…
A Tucker Carlson history of Japan. https://t.co/QWK9Bfodvu
What? Dresden was bombed? This secret must be discussed. https://t.co/WwdfgotBjl
Sorry @benshapiro but @TuckerCarlson's right. Dropping the atom bomb on Japan was evil Many conservatives said this. Saying it isn't "left-wing" National Review 1959: "The indefensibility of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima is becoming a part of the national conservative creed." https://t.co/H7EADnzSNG
BEN SHAPIRO’S GENOCIDAL STATEMENT https://t.co/kWM4OhLjCT
Dresden was a city in Germany that was bombed indiscriminately in 1945 The city had zero military targets Germany was already near surrender but we had bloodlust on our hands Estimates of how many people we killed range between 24,000 and 200,000 in 3 days https://t.co/ZhuEOep1kY
Contra Tucker Carlson, the US was justified in saving lives by bombing Japan https://t.co/U9i0X0DcJl https://t.co/U9i0X0DcJl
Dresden was way more destroyed with way more loss of life than Hiroshima or Nagasaki. As “the right” with boomer brain debates rather or not the alleged atomic bombs were good or bad, isn’t it odd that no one discusses Dresden? Or the 13 other Japanese cities more destroyed?…
It's disrespectful to the Japanese to say that anything short of two atom bombs combined with the Soviet invasion of Manchuria would have compelled surrender. People need to go be moralfags about something else tbqh and leave 1945 alone.
General Eisenhower said Japan was in the process of surrendering when we dropped the bombs and were unnecessary 300,000 civilians were killed simply as a show of force They weren't Jewish so Ben Shapiro approves https://t.co/r4TvIS1Bkd
Ben Shapiro responds to Tucker Carlson: "No, America was not evil for dropping the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki." https://t.co/OHWgmg8ika
It was a good thing to nuke Hiroshima and Nagasaki. It would have been a good thing to nuke Berlin if it had been an option earlier in the war. Sherman's March to the Sea was not just morally acceptable, it was a moral requirement. Replies are turned off. Not sorry.
Tucker with a long diatribe on why he now believes the U.S. should not have bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki and instead used conventional forces which would have resulted in millions more dead and the Soviet Union occupying a large part of Japan. https://t.co/9PQedxQVk9
Tucker Carlson says dropping a nuclear bomb on Japan was evil. It is in fact internationally recognised as a war crime. If Hitler had nuked the US and used the excuse that he was saving the lives of soldiers no one would buy it. https://t.co/1wMBuo7BPS
This is actually untrue Japan was in the process of negotiating terms of surrender with Russia before the bombs were dropped They didn't want to be raped and tortured like the Germans Even Dwight Eisenhower said it was completely unnecessary and never should have happened https://t.co/7R6uqsDtvw
Tucker is way off, here. Dropping the bombs on Japan was the only option. I know that’s an unpopular view in this day but it’s the truth. https://t.co/XxL8rEjXIj
Dropping nukes on innocent people is evil.
“Dropping nukes on civilians is wrong.” Yes! Unless you ask people about 1945 for some reason https://t.co/2pcTRyMtW1
For those who support America dropping atomic bombs on Japan, just know both Gen Arnold and Eisenhower were vehemently against it and said Japan would surrender without it. This debate is nonsense https://t.co/yapP4kNAuC
Even Tucker loses the plot on this own. It’s a MORAL DILEMMA. Both choices lead to evil and human suffering. That is war. It’s not a matter of if innocents die or get tortured. It’s how many. Preventing the red army from occupying Japan was a great choice for humanity. https://t.co/JWO0MaX4O5
Sometimes doing evil leads to a better outcome. The atomic bombs on Japan is an example. Look into what the Red Army did to innocent German children. You’ll lose sleep. Ending the war spared millions of Japanese from suffering and stopped the evil USSR from occupying Japan.
Tucker Carlson says anyone who defends nuclear bombs being dropped is defending evil. "If you find yourself arguing that it's a good thing to drop nuclear weapons on people, then you are evil." https://t.co/MhCptHLTIE